My votes for legends...
Best Large PVP Guild Pre:UoR (KoC) Chesapeke, Siege. I do not care how good your guild was, or how skilled they were, KoC had 20-30 active members a night all 7x. This is when people had 60 resist on average per guild. They also had 5 of the top ten duelers in probably all of UO at the time. Tree was probably the best dueler they had. I had some good fights with him, as FiZBaN.
Best Guild UoR (OiN) Chesapeke. When they were active there was not a better guild at crosshealing or tactics then OiN. They had some good duelers, but were great groupfighters. Imrahil and Cadul were two people anyone would have wanted to fight with.
Best Duelers Preuor (I consider now, since back in the day people were horrible at dueling, and it is pointless to argue "epic duels" when 50 percent of IPY would destroy anyone from back then) I was a great dueler in Pre UoR and I would destroy myself now at it, most likely on the first two dumps. I really dont even consider it that skilled anymore
. Exp, equip hally, hally hit, release exp, magic arrow, ebolt, equip hally, weaken, weaken, weaken hally hit. Still the only people to beat me at it, or that I know would give me a good fight were.
Xmyth: By far the best preuor dueler I have ever seen. This is all he plays though. He hates UOR, but was pretty good at it. Only guy I ever fought preuor that killed me more then I killed him.
Ironfist Max: (He was always great at tanks, even though his connection sucked in preuor)
Demon Arkanis: This guy beat everyone he ever fought but me and Xmyth
Tomoyaki: I would rank him below arkanis but he was good.
Temptest: (Another good UOR player that loves tanks, and could easily adapt)
All the rest of the "legends" were only legends on OSI when everyone sucked. These guys could fight with the best of the Pre UoR players now. Shoot I killed most people OSI Preuor by just double hally hitting and casting weaken.
Best PvP'rs UOR
Heal mages:
Valkyr: Probably the best 7 x healer mage to ever play
Rage: As good or second to Valkyr as a heal mage.
Chrome: Plays European shards, and my ping sucks there, but he was badass.
Tank Mages:
Ironfist Max (Tank mages are his first, best destiny, noone does it better)
Temptest (Awesome tank mage)
Other then that the rest use magic weapons and precast poison. These are the only tank mages I consider skilled.
5x Mages:
Trunks: Humble, but when he is on his game hes hard as hell to kill. He seems alot like me in that he has good and bad fights. I think he has my impatience hehe.
Trixta: Balance, cool head, always a threat.
Woel Chuck: Strong offense and best defense on shard, balanced, cool head, doesnt fuck up, I can kill him but I think he would beat me in best of 2-3 long fights I just dont have patience or a cool head like him.
El Oh Dee : Great offense, decent defense.
Steve (Marctor from chessy) He dueled me three times and lost, but his timing looks good, and I think he will be top 5 in no time. Great offense, needs to work on defense.
Mike York: This guy has absolutely no offense, and does not have wrestling, but his defense is great, he would be great if he could time his combos better.
InBiZaBlE: he just needs a little work on his timing and he will be good. Like me he grows impatient with duels over one minute long lol.
Field Fighters:
It is impossible to tell, since everyone uses tamers and pots.
Of the people that dont I would say Ironfist Max is one I would most likely want by my side.
Anyways those are the people that impress me and I dont impress easily.